Sugar Addiction: Myth or Your Brain on Science?
“I’m addicted to chocolate.” Who hasn’t said or heard that phrase at some point?
We’re just talking here. No judgment, no lectures. Just this legitimate question: is sugar addiction a modern myth or scientific reality?
Because let’s be honest, when you’re mentally planning your supermarket route around the candy aisle, or developing spy-level strategies to hide your chocolate stash, you have every right to wonder what’s going on.
So what’s really happening in our brains when sugar catches our eye?
This question deserves some serious attention. Because behind these everyday moments, there might be very real neurological mechanisms at work, important health implications, and most importantly, answers that could finally help us understand why some of us have this complicated relationship with sweet stuff.
Let’s explore the facts together and separate the myths from reality.
Here is a five-minute glimpse into the world of addiction, an eye-opening illustration that reveals how powerful and insidious our relationship with certain foods can be.
I eat it because I like it
Just like a smoker is convinced they smoke because they think they love the taste of cigarettes, some people think they overeat simply because they love the taste of their favorite foods. But really, do you think it’s just about taste?
I love the taste of asparagus. That said, I don’t think about it all day long. Once I’ve had some, I don’t crave it to the point where I can’t stop. I don’t ask my dinner companion if they’re going to finish theirs while secretly hoping they’ll say no. I don’t usually need to mobilize all my willpower to avoid “giving in” to asparagus when I see it or smell it. And I’m definitely not looking for excuses to go hunt some down at 11 PM at the only store open in town.
But the picture is completely different for our “favorite” foods – those processed, often sugary products (cookies, chocolate, chips…) that we’re actually hooked on. There’s that persistent mental image of a specific food, that insatiable and irrepressible craving. It’s so stubborn that it persists until we finally eat the forbidden fruit. This food obsession is a response to a mental and physical compulsion that’s beyond our control or willpower. It’s an addiction.
Before we go further, what foods are we actually talking about?
What everyone should know about sugar
Carbohydrates, formerly called hydrates of carbon, are a group of substances made up of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen atoms.
There are different types of carbohydrates:
- Simple sugars (monosaccharides)
- Glucose (or dextrose). Sources: fruits, honey, small amounts in most plants
- Fructose. Sources: fruits, honey, small amounts in most plants
- Galactose. Sources: dairy products
- Complex sugars (disaccharides)
- Sucrose. Sources: white table sugar and all products where it’s added: ice cream, cookies, candy, chocolate, pastries, jam, sauces, prepared meals…
- Lactose (sources: milk, dairy products)
- Maltose (sources: cereals, pie crusts, breadcrumbs, beer)
- Complex sugars (polysaccharides)
- Amylose + Amylopectin. Sources: bread, cereals, pasta, potatoes. This is how plants store carbohydrates
- Glycogen (sources: liver, muscles). In humans, sugar is stored in limited amounts in muscles (about 300-500g) and in the liver (about 100-150g) as glycogen
Our body only absorbs carbohydrates in the form of simple sugars. All complex sugars (potatoes, pasta, chips, cereals…) are always broken down in the small intestine into their individual sugar components.
By the way, the concept of slow or fast sugars is wrong! All carbohydrates generally have more or less the same intestinal absorption speed. Complex carbohydrates are just simple carbohydrates holding hands.
In this article, the term SUGAR therefore includes all carbohydrates in processed products (ice cream, cookies, chocolate, bread, pizza, pasta, chips, cereals…). You’ll find a list of most sugars here (think about printing it and bringing it with you when you shop).
Why we love sweet stuff so much
We’re programmed to love fatty and sugary products. Our brain interprets them as being rich in energy. And humans have always needed energy – whether for hunting, traveling long distances, or escaping from lions.
However, naturally sugar-rich products were rare in nature. Back then, our only sources of carbohydrates were tubers, fruits, berries, or honey that humans found during their explorations.
Today, we’re facing an unnatural overabundance of artificially sweetened products. Sugar is available everywhere, in unlimited quantities. Despite health warnings, we eat it without restraint. Except nowadays, we rarely need to escape from lions…
Food manufacturers have clearly understood our strong taste and biochemical preference and exploit it excessively and unscrupulously by adding sugar to almost all packaged foods.
“Okay, but sugar makes me happy and I like eating it. Does that make me addicted?”
Is sugar addiction real?
- Addiction
First, what is addiction?
Addiction can be defined according to these 11 criteria from the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders), the reference manual published by the American Psychiatric Association (APA):
1. Repeated use of a substance leading to inability to fulfill major obligations (at work, school, or home)
2. Repeated use of a substance in situations where it could be physically dangerous
3. Craving or urgent desire to consume
4. Use of the substance despite persistent or recurring interpersonal or social problems caused or made worse by the substance’s effects
5. Tolerance, manifested by either:
- Need for increasingly larger amounts of the substance to achieve intoxication or the desired effect
- Markedly diminished effects with continued use of the same amount of substance
6. Withdrawal (“craving”) shown by either:
- Appearance of withdrawal symptoms, which vary by substance
- The same substance (or another) is consumed to relieve or avoid withdrawal symptoms
7. Substance taken in larger amounts or for longer periods than the person intended
8. Persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to reduce or control substance use
9. Considerable time spent obtaining the substance, consuming it, or recovering from its effects
10. Abandoning or reducing activities (social, work, leisure) because of substance use
11. Continued use of the substance despite knowing about a persistent or recurring physical or psychological problem
These criteria evaluate addictive behaviors (consumption of nicotine, alcohol, heroin but also video games, pornography, gambling…).
There is a “disorder” when at least two of these eleven criteria appear over a 12-month period.
One bite is too much… and a thousand is never enough.
- Food addiction
The concept of food addiction first appeared in 1956. Theron Randolph, a doctor, already recognized that “a specific adaptation to one or more regularly consumed foods to which a person is highly sensitive produces a common pattern of symptoms descriptively similar to those of other dependency processes“.
Dr. Randolph certainly didn’t reach this conclusion by observing a patient who had abused asparagus.
Natural, whole foods and animal products don’t inspire destructive behavior, unlike factory-made products manufactured with food extracts, reassembled together, flavored and given an irresistible texture.
So the problem isn’t really isolated sugar. Do you know many people who eat white sugar by the spoonful?
The real problem is what we do to food. Sugar is the active element of dependency, but processed products are the vehicle.
Some people can’t stop. Others hide, lie, or manipulate those around them to disguise their consumption. Eating in inappropriate places or at inappropriate times is another warning sign. Getting food by any means or eating at any hour is also risky behavior.
- Where it all begins
A child who grows up in an atmosphere of emotional distance, who doesn’t receive emotional warmth, grows up with a fear of being abandoned. A child who doesn’t learn that they’re valued, appreciated, cherished, loved… is an ideal candidate for developing an addiction. That child learns to survive, but not to live. Not knowing how to turn to others for help, they turn to an object or behavior to cover their fundamental emotional needs. Food thus becomes an automatic response to emotions.
However, addiction isn’t just psychological. Excessive and prolonged sugar consumption causes disruption in hormone and neurotransmitter levels to such an extent that it results in biochemical imbalance. Thus, addiction is also physical. Signs of physical dependency can be:
- increased tolerance to effects (you need to eat more to get the same effect)
- physical withdrawal symptoms when you stop sugar
Addiction to processed products is very real. Unfortunately, it’s very socially accepted.
It’s hard to find your bearings in a society that pushes us toward consuming sugary products. Especially since many people aren’t dependent on these products. Some can eat two squares of chocolate and say “this is too rich for me, I’ve had enough”.
Addicts, however, have a completely different response in their brain and can’t stop at two squares of chocolate or two chips.
There’s no doubt that for dependent people who can’t control their consumption, pleasure quickly turns into a nightmare.
The chemical trap of dependency
The pleasure mechanism is deeply inscribed in our brain. Pleasure neurotransmitters – serotonin, dopamine, endorphins – are released during pleasant activities that ensure our survival (eating, sex…). Serenity comes when we have balance between all neurotransmitters.
Sugar, extracted, concentrated and pre-chewed in processed foods, overstimulates our nervous system and overactivates the reward system. Neither green beans nor a beef steak trigger this cascade of endorphins.
Science is increasingly catching up with patient testimonies and addiction stories. One study measured sugar’s impact on the brain and reward circuit. Participants who weren’t used to eating sugar often had a strong dopamine release. The reward circuit activated strongly.
However, for people regularly consuming sugary foods, there was practically no activation. The sugar we consume regularly changes our brain. As a result, constant consumption of sugary foods reduces the pleasure we feel when eating them. We therefore need to increase quantities to feel the same level of pleasure.
Except processed products don’t give us nutrients our body needs. We eat more and more, without ever being satisfied. Now addiction sets in.
Here’s why you still don’t believe in sugar addiction
You’re skeptical about the very notion of sugar addiction? That’s normal! Let’s review 5 common statements of food dependency denial.
- Food addiction isn’t real. There’s no scientific evidence to prove the existence of food addiction
Taking pleasure in eating certainly doesn’t mean we’re dependent. The question is: where do we draw the line between taste enjoyment and distress caused by uncontrollable binges on processed products?
To take the example of alcohol, just because some people can control their consumption doesn’t mean alcoholism doesn’t exist. For many it’s a reality, even a daily nightmare. You wouldn’t think of advising an alcoholic to control themselves or limit their consumption to “just two beers on Saturday night”.
Similar to alcohol, sugar addicts are powerless against their dependency. Consequently, they can’t “just eat less” or “eat only 2 cookies”. It’s a mental obession, which is actually not so difficult to overcome.
- Eating sugar is natural, our body needs it to function. Eliminating sugar is dangerous for health
It’s true that our brain needs about 120 grams of carbohydrates per day to function. However, we haven’t always had sweetened yogurts and cakes for dessert. So how did humans not only survive but also develop for 300,000 years?
Although neurons depend on glucose to function, we don’t need to eat it! As I explain in this article, our body knows very well how to make glucose on its own, and in case of shortage, it actually prioritizes brain cells to ensure they function well.
- Nobody forces people to eat, they’re solely responsible for their weight gain
For decades, tobacco manufacturers denied that nicotine is addictive even though their internal research proved otherwise. The blame was placed on consumers. They just need to smoke less!
Similarly, the food industry does everything today to erase the addiction their processed products can cause. They shift responsibility onto the consumer and not onto the products.
This is a misunderstanding (or intentional ignorance) of addiction mechanisms, of powerlessness against physical cravings, of mental obsessions.
An irrepressible craving for a sweet, fatty and/or very salty food or a need to eat in large quantities is different from real physical hunger. Hunger signals to the mind that the body needs nutrients. Craving signals that the mind/body must eat – it’s like false hunger. Ultimately, addicts feel that their life is potentially in danger if they don’t eat that particular food immediately.
The solution remains total abstinence from processed foods that trigger uncontrollable sugar cravings. In other words, avoid products that make you crack as much as possible. You could for example try the ketogenic diet which has the advantage of excluding craving-triggering products.
- Some people are able to eat sugar and maintain their weight. I should be able to do it too.
First, weight isn’t an indicator of good health. A person can be thin while having visceral fat around their internal organs. This fat, invisible to the naked eye, is dangerous for health. It’s pro-inflammatory and increases the risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, bad cholesterol, type 2 diabetes…
Second, our microbiome has the same bacterial groups. However, each individual has proportions that are unique to them – that’s the uniqueness of the microbiome. Consequently, we don’t digest a cookie the same way. The intestinal bacteria of the microbiome are unique, our dopaminergic response is different, our hormone balance also varies. Certainly, we’re not all equal when facing the same food.
Are you hooked?
Are you dependent on food or do you simply love eating? Maybe you’re an emotional eater without going as far as addiction.
How do you know if it’s a real dependency?
Consider the following statements:
- I’ve already tried to control my consumption without success
- I’m constantly preoccupied with my weight or with food
- I chain together diets, but never maintain results long-term
- When I’m alone, I eat differently than when I’m with other people
- I try to compensate for overeating through exercise, fasting, vomiting or laxatives
- I eat to escape my emotions
- Sometimes I eat even though I’m no longer hungry
- I’ve resisted food before but still went to get some shortly after
- I’ve stolen food before
- I’ve made reserves or hidden food to make sure I always have enough
- Calculating the calories I consume and burn is an obsession for me
- I often feel guilty or ashamed about what I eat
- I feel hopeless about my eating behavior
If you’ve observed at least 3 of these behaviors over the past 12 months, you’re certainly dependent.
The good news is that you don’t have to be and there is an easy way out.
Dr TARMAN Vera, “Food Junkies, The Truth About Food Addiction”, Dundurn, 2014
WERDELL M.A., Philip, “Food Addiction Denial: False Information and Irrational Thinking”, BookBaby, 2022
NAKKEN Craig, “The Addictive Personality: Understanding the Addictive Process and Compulsive Behavior”, Hazelden Trade, 1988
KATHERINE Anne, Food Addiction: The Brain Chemistry of Overeating, Gurze Books, 1997
Copyright ©Nutrinama Ekaterina Choukel
The contents of this blog, including text, images and statistics as well as any other material on this website (referred below as “content”) are for informational purposes only. The content is not intended to be a substitute for medical diagnosis and/or treatment and is not suitable for self-administration without the knowledge of your doctor. Do not disregard medical advice and always consult your doctor for concerns you might have regarding your health condition or before acting on anything you have read or heard in our content.